Best Pietta 1858 Sheriff: A Comprehensive Review Of Authentic Replica Revolver 

Are you in the market for an authentic replica revolver? The Pietta 1858 Sheriff is a great choice if you’re looking for a reliable and well-crafted weapon that accurately replicates the classic look of 19th century revolvers. 

This comprehensive review will take an in-depth look at the features, performance, and overall value of this popular firearm. We’ll discuss its design elements, construction materials, accuracy and reliability tests, as well as other important considerations so that you can make an informed decision when purchasing your next revolver. So let’s get started!

Pietta 1858 Sheriff Comparison 2024

Bestseller No. 1
Premium Leather Paddle OWB Revolver Holster with Retention Strap Fits Pietta 1858, 44 Cal Remington Sheriff 5.5'' Octagon Barrel Black Powder Revolver, Right Hand Draw, Brown Color #1579#
  • USBR // Made from Premium Genuine Leather. Hand-made molding for a perfect fit.
  • The retention strap helps keep the gun securely in place. Retention strap has a snap closure on the front of the holster. A plastic tab on the holster strap provides fast pulls.
  • Adjustable tension screw for customized retention. Sight rail space to protect the leather and muzzle sight. High and tight carry. Effective concealment with maximum comfort.
  • Has a moving polymer paddle to adjust the carrying angle. Using 2 screws on the polymer paddle the holster can be rotated up to 45 degrees each way with a screwdriver.
  • It can be easily adjusted to wear on the Strong Side, Cross-Draw. Zero cant, forward cant, and rearward cant. Fits up to 1 3/4" wide belts.
Bestseller No. 2
Leather Paddle OWB Revolver Holster Open Top Fits Pietta 1858, 44 Cal Remington Sheriff 5.5'' Octagon Barrel Black Powder Revolver, R/H Draw, Brown Color #1579#
  • USCA // Made from Premium Genuine Leather. Hand-made molding for a perfect fit.
  • Open top for fast drawing. High and tight carry. Adjustable tension screw for customized retention. Sight rail space to protect the leather and muzzle sight.
  • Has a moving polymer paddle to adjust the carrying angle. Using 2 screws on the polymer paddle the holster can be rotated up to 45 degrees each way with a screwdriver.
  • It can be easily adjusted to wear on the Strong Side, Cross-Draw. Zero cant, forward cant, and rearward cant. Fits up to 1 3/4" wide belts.
  • PLEASE NOTE: The holster may appear to fit too tight at first and when holstering your gun the first time. This is for long usage of your holster, considering the fact that the leather will relax with use.

Pietta 1858 Sheriff Reviews 2024

Best For The Reliability-Denix Model 1892 Lever-Action Cowboy Rifle

Denix Model 1892 Lever-Action Cowboy Rifle - Non-Firing Replica
  • Mod. 92 Carbine Cowboy Version - USA 1892
  • Overall Length: 37 1/8" : Weight: 5lb 13oz: Barrel Length: 19"
  • This product is restricted from shipment into the state of New York

The Denix Model 1892 Lever-Action Cowboy Rifle is an excellent choice for those looking for an authentic and reliable lever-action rifle. From its overall length of 37 1/8″ to its 19″ barrel, it provides great accuracy and precision when shooting, while also being lightweight and easy to carry. 

Not only that, but it is restricted from shipment into the state of New York for extra safety assurance,so you can rest assured that it will remain safe and secure. All things considered, this is a great choice for any hunter or shooter looking for an authentic lever-action firearm.

Pros:

– Accurate and precise when shooting 

– Lightweight and easy to carry

– Restricted from shipment into the state of New York for extra safety assurance 

Cons:

– None identified

Best For The Design-Denix 1866 Lever-Action

Denix 1866 Lever-Action Repeating Replica Gun (Brass) - Non-Firing Replica
  • This is famous for its rugged construction and lever-action breech mechanism
  • Overall length: 37 inch; weight - 8 lbs 6 oz
  • The 1866 was only available in .44 caliber rimfire cartridge at first
  • Its tubular magazine was located underneath the barrel
  • This item is not for sale in some specific zip codes

The Denix 1866 Lever-Action is a reliable and well-crafted firearm that is sure to please any gun enthusiast. It has an overall length of 37 inches and weighs 8 lbs 6 oz, making it ideal for easy handling. Its .44 caliber rimfire cartridge can provide plenty of stopping power and its tubular magazine located underneath the barrel ensures that you’ll have plenty of ammunition on hand for whatever the situation may be.

 We would highly recommend the Denix 1866 Lever-Action to anyone looking for a reliable and dependable gun. It is restricted from shipment into the state of New York, so please take note before ordering.

Pros:

– Reliable and well-crafted firearm 

– Ideal for easy handling with a length of 37 inches and weight of 8 lbs 6 oz

– Equipped with .44 caliber rimfire cartridge for plenty of stopping power 

– Tubular magazine located underneath the barrel ensures plenty of ammunition on hand. 

Cons

– Not available for shipment into the state of New York.

Best For The Style-Denix Model 1873 Lever Action Rifle

Denix Model 1873 Lever Action Rifle, Antique Grey Finish - Non-Firing Replica
  • This is a non-firing version.
  • This product is restricted from shipment into the state of New York

The Denix Model 1873 Lever Action Rifle is an iconic piece of Western history. Developed from the Henry rifle, this lever-action repeating rifle was known for its strength and reliability. With a capacity to fire multiple shots before the need to reload, the Model 1873 was a popular choice among cowboys and frontiersmen alike. This non-firing replica is a great way to get an authentic feel for this classic weapon. 

It looks and feels just like the original, giving you a chance to transport yourself back in time without having to worry about the risks associated with handling a real rifle. If you’re looking for a piece of history or a conversation starter, then the Denix Model 1873 Lever Action Rifle is a great choice.

Pros:

– Non-firing replica for a safe and authentic experience 

– Iconic piece of Western history 

– Looks and feels just like the original rifle 

– Great conversation starter or decoration piece  

Cons:

– Does not fire real ammunition, so cannot be used as a weapon

Best For Everyone-Benjamin Sheridan, Remington 1875

Sale
Remington RR1875 CO2-Powered Full Metal Pellet/BB Revolver
  • WESTERN-STYLE DESIGN - Classic Remington 1875 replica
  • CO2-POWERED - Single action (CO2 not included)
  • DUAL AMMO - .177-caliber pellets or 4.5mm BBs (pellets and BBs not included)
  • NICKEL FINISH AND FAUX IVORY GRIP - Authentic look and feel
  • FUNCTIONAL HAMMER, LOAD GATE AND EXTRACTOR

The Benjamin Sheridan Remington 1875 is a realistic replica of the original revolver and has a beautiful nickel finish. This single action revolver performs with precision accuracy, making it an ideal choice for collectors and re-enactors alike. Although the design may be old and outdated, the craftsmanship of this piece shines through as it boasts all the features of the original Remington 1875. 

This classic revolver is sure to make a great addition to any gun collection and will surely be admired for generations to come.  All in all, this replica of the legendary Remington 1875 is an excellent choice for those looking for a timeless firearm with unparalleled quality.

Pros

– Realistic Remington 1875 replica

– Single Action

– Nickel Finish for a stylish look and feel 

Cons

– Not ideal for self defense as it is designed to be more of a recreational gun.

Best For The Material-Denix P-08 German Luger Naval

Denix P-08 German Luger Naval World War-I World War-II Non-Firing Replica Pistol Wooden Grip
  • Country Of Origin: Spain
  • Model Number: 22-1144L
  • Item Package Dimension: 11.8" L x 4.5" W x 1.5" H
  • Item Package Weight: 3.0 lb

The Denix P-08 German Luger Naval is an exceptional firearm that offers a classic look with modern features. Not only does it have the iconic design of the classic German Luger, but it also has a full metal construction for improved durability and longevity. The model number of 22-1144L ensures that you get the highest quality craftsmanship, and the item package dimensions of 11.8″ L x 4.5″ W x 1.5″ H make it easy to store and transport. 

The item package weight of 3.0 pounds is surprisingly light for a metal firearm, allowing you to carry it with ease while still having reliable performance in any environment. With its exquisite craftsmanship and classic design, the Denix P-08 German Luger Naval is a great choice for any collector or gun enthusiast.

Pros:

– Full metal construction for improved durability and longevity

– Model number of 22-1144L ensures highest quality craftsmanship 

– Item package dimensions of 11.8″ L x 4.5″ W x 1.5″ H make it easy to store and transport 

Cons

– Not a modern firearm, so certain features may be lacking compared to other models

Denix M1861 Navy Issue Brass

Denix M1861 Navy Issue Brass Revolver - Non-Firing Replica
  • During the Civil War, the Union Army purchased almost 130,000 pieces
  • The gun was a .44 caliber, six shot, front-loader that took linen or paper cartridges
  • This non-firing replica has the handling characteristics of the original
  • Overall Length: 14 5/8"; weight - 2lbs 8oz; Barrel Length 7 3/4-inch
  • This item is not for sale in some specific zip codes

Revisit the Civil War with Denix’s historically accurate non-firing replica of a classic Union Army weapon. The M1861 Navy Issue Brass is an exact copy of the .44 caliber, six shot front-loader used by 130,000 soldiers during wartime – complete in its 14 5/8″ frame and 7 3/4 inch barrel. Weighing just 2lbs 8ozs it allows you to channel your inner soldier without compromising on quality or authenticity.

This replica is designed to have the handling characteristics of the original, making it great for collectors or reenactment use. However, please note that this item is not for sale in certain zip codes. All in all, this is an impressive replica of a classic weapon. 

Pros

– Historically accurate replica of a classic Union Army weapon

– Barrel length of 7 3/4″ and overall length of 14 5/8″ 

– Designed to have the handling characteristics of the original 

– Great for collectors or reenactment use 

Cons

– Not available in certain zip codes

Denix 1851 Engraved Navy Revolver

Sale
Denix 1851 Engraved Navy Revolver, Silver - Non-Firing Replica
  • Functional Lock Mechanism
  • All Metal with Faux Ivory Grips
  • Museum Quality Reproduction

The Denix 1851 Engraved Navy Revolver is an exquisite piece of history, and a perfect example of the artistry of 19th century factory engravers. This beautiful reproduction non-firing revolver was based on the military-issue 1851 Navy revolver, which saw service through the end of the Civil War and was given to high-ranking military officers and government officials. 

The intricate engraving on the metal frame reflects the precision of craftsmanship in those times, adding a unique touch to an already impressive weapon. An excellent conversation piece that will bring history into your home, it is truly an amazing reproduction. 

Pros:

• Exquisite piece of history 

• Perfect example of 19th century factory engraving artistry 

• Intricate engraving on metal frame reflecting precision craftsmanship  

• Conversation piece that brings history into your home 

Cons

• Non-firing replica – cannot be used for hunting or target practice

Umarex Legends Lever Action Cowboy Rifle .177

No products found.

The Umarex Legends Lever Action Cowboy Rifle .177 is a truly remarkable recreation of the classic 1894 rifle of the Wild West. This air rifle has an authentic lever action that realistically spits shells when operated and shoots .177 caliber steel BBs at up to 600 fps. The gun is powered by two 12-gram CO2 cartridges which are housed in the stock and comes with 10 BB cartridge casings. 

With adjustable rear sights and a fixed front sight, this air rifle is perfect for plinking, target practice and reenactments. All-in-all, the Umarex Legends Lever Action Cowboy Rifle .177 is an excellent choice for those looking to bring a bit of the Wild West into their home. Enjoy the sights and sounds of this unique air rifle! 

Pros: 

– Authentic lever action for realistic shots and shells when operated 

– Adjustable rear sight and fixed front sight

– Shoots .177 caliber steel BBs at up to 600 fps 

– Powered by two 12 gram CO2 cartridges housed inside the stock

– Comes with 10 BB cartridge casings 

Cons

– Limited range of motion on lever

Denix DX1228-BRK 

SOFT AIR USA Colt M4A1 M4 CQBR AEG Electric Airsoft Rifle with Adjustable Hop-Up, Black, 453 FPS
  • Velocity: 395 FPS w/.20g BBs
  • Mag Cap: 350 rds
  • Full Colt trademarks
  • Metal outer barrel, charging handle, and magazine release
  • Adjustable stock

The Denix DX1228-BRK is an excellent choice for anyone looking for a high-quality replica sword or dagger. It is made in Spain, using the highest standards and strictest of quality control to ensure its authenticity and craftsmanship. The blade is made from high carbon steel, providing exceptional resistance to rust and corrosion. 

This piece is also a great display piece, as its detailed design and rich finish will draw attention in any room. It also makes a great gift for the collector of swords or daggers. All in all, the Denix DX1228-BRK is an impressive replica sword that offers quality and craftsmanship at an affordable price. 

 Pros:

– High carbon steel blade for exceptional resistance to rust and corrosion 

– Detailed design with a rich finish 

– Affordable price point

– Makes a great gift or display piece 

Cons:

– Not designed for actual combat

Denix Left Handed English Flintlock Pistol

Sale
Denix Left Handed English Flintlock Pistol, Gray
  • Non-Firing Replica
  • Museum Quality Historical Reproduction
  • Gray Finish
  • Country Of Origin : Spain

The Denix Left Handed English Flintlock Pistol is a stunning historical reproduction of a classic design. This museum-quality replica looks and feels just like the real thing, with its gray finish and heavy construction giving it an air of authenticity. It’s made in Spain to exacting specifications, and its non-firing mechanism ensures safety while still allowing you to experience the look and feel of a real 18th-century flintlock pistol.

This beautiful reproduction features a painted wood grip, with detailed engraving along the entire length of its barrel and frame. It has a working trigger and hammer action, giving it realistic handling capabilities. The Denix Left Handed English Flintlock Pistol also comes with a wooden presentation box for storage and display. 

Add this classic piece to your collection and experience the look and feel of an authentic 18th-century flintlock pistol.Whether you’re a collector or just looking for an impressive decorative piece, this Denix Left Handed English Flintlock Pistol is sure to impress. It’s the perfect addition to any collection!

Pros:

– Museum-quality replica of classic design

– Gray finish and heavy construction to give an authentic look and feel 

– Exacting specifications for accuracy and safety 

– Perfect addition to any collection as a decorative piece 

Cons

– Non firing mechanism ensures safety but does not provide the feeling of a real 18th century flintlock pistol

Parris Kadet Trainerifle

No products found.

The Parris Kadet Trainerifle is a great choice for aspiring marksmen and gun enthusiasts alike. With its 1903 Springfield style silver plated detail, this 41.5 inch long bolt action rifle has a removable break-away sling, as well as a clicker trigger for ease of use. 

This rifle is specifically designed to simulate the feel and accuracy of a real firearm, making it perfect for those looking to hone their skills before taking on the challenge of a real gun. Thanks to its detailed construction and reliable design, this rifle is sure to provide shooters with hours of fun target practice.

Pros:

– 1903 Springfield style silver plated detail for an authentic look and feel 

– 41.5 inch long bolt action rifle with removable break-away sling

– Clicker trigger for ease of use and accuracy simulation 

– Reliable design and construction allows for hours of target practice 

Cons

– No ammunition or accessories included in purchase

Denix M1860 Army Issue

Denix M1860 Army Issue Revolver, Grey - Non-Firing Replica
  • It is the most-used revolver in the conflict
  • The gun was a .44 caliber, six shot, front-loader that took linen or paper cartridges
  • This non-firing replica has the handling characteristics of the original, with functional lock and loading mechanisms
  • Overall Length: 14 5/8 inches; weight - 2lbs 8oz; Barrel Length 7 3/4 inches
  • This item is not for sale in some specific zip codes

The Denix M1860 Army Issue is an impressive replica of a historic firearm from the Civil War. It is a .44 caliber, six shot, front-loader that took linen or paper cartridges and could fire up to 15 rounds per minute. This non-firing replica has all the same handling characteristics as the original, with functional lock and loading mechanisms.

 It is lightweight, at 2lbs 8oz and its overall length of 14 5/8 inches makes for easy portability. The Denix M1860 Army Issue would make a great addition to any collection or as an interesting display item. Be aware, however, that this item is not available for sale in certain zip codes.

Pros: 

– Lightweight, at 2lbs 8oz and its overall length of 14 5/8 inches making it easy to carry around

– Functional lock and loading mechanisms 

– Makes a great addition to any collection or as an interesting display item 

Cons

– Not available for sale in certain zip codes

Barra Airguns Schofield No. 3

No products found.

The Barra Airguns Schofield No. 3 is a stunning replica of the original Smith & Wesson revolver from 1875. It is a full metal airgun with precision craftsmanship and attention to detail that makes it an excellent choice for movie props or costumes. With a single action CO2 power, this small but mighty six shooter can reach up to 435 fps with its 7-inch barrel and 12g co2 cartridges.  

Its realistic features and heavy-duty construction make it a great choice for sports shooting and target practice. Its adjustable rear sights, manual safety catch, and textured handle provide extra accuracy when aiming. The Barra Airguns Schofield No. 3 is a unique gun that will turn heads when displayed in your collection or used on the range. 

It’s sure to be a hit with anyone who loves classic guns and airsoft. With its powerful performance, realistic features, and impressive construction, the Barra Airguns Schofield No. 3 is sure to become a favorite in any collection. 

An added bonus is the 1 year warranty, so you can be sure this collector’s piece will stand up to your shooting needs. Lead pellets are sold separately for maximum range and accuracy, making the Barra Airguns Schofield No. 3 a great choice for target shooting and competitions.

Pros:

– Full metal construction for realistic weight and feel 

– High velocity of up to 435 fps with 12g CO2 cartridges 

– Precision craftsmanship with attention to detail 

– Comes with a 1 year warranty 

– Lead pellets sold separately for maximum accuracy and range 

Cons:

– Not suitable for younger children due to its powerful performance

Denix 18th Century Flintlock Musket

The Denix 18th Century Flintlock Musket is an impressive replica of the musket used on the European battlefields during the Napoleonic wars. This non-firing version has been used in several movies and makes a great wall decoration. 

This musket has a full-length barrel and is made of sturdy steel with an antique finish. Its stock is made of hardwood, giving it realistic weight and feel. The lock plate, trigger guard, butt plate, side plate, and ramrod are all detailed and accurate. It also comes with a sling swivel and a ramrod. 

This Denix musket is a must-have for anyone who’s interested in the Napoleonic era or wants to add an authentic piece of history to their collection. Whether you’re looking to show off your knowledge of this period of history or simply want to own a replica that looks and feels like the real thing, the Denix 18th Century Flintlock Musket is the perfect choice. Plus, with its antique finish, it’s sure to add a touch of class to any room! 

Pros:

– Intricate detailing and realistic lock mechanisms

– Non-firing version, used in several movies

– Fitted with bayonet for use in close quarters 

– Accurate reproduction of a French flintlock rifle 

– Great conversation piece for any collector or history enthusiast 

Cons:

– Not suitable for firing real ammunition

Denix Kentucky Flintlock Pistol, Brass

Denix Kentucky Flintlock Pistol, Brass
  • Non-Firing Replica
  • Museum Quality Historical Reproduction
  • Brass Finish
  • Country Of Origin : Spain

The Denix Kentucky Flintlock Pistol is a stunning replica of the original 18th century pistol. Made from solid brass, it is both rust-resistant and hard wearing, with a beautiful finish that gives it a timeless appearance. The hammer and trigger are highly detailed, designed to look as close to the original parts as possible. 

This faithful recreation of a classic American sidearm is sure to make an impression on any history enthusiast. It’s perfect for display, or even used as a prop in theatrical performances. Overall, the Denix Kentucky Flintlock Pistol is an impressive reproduction of a timeless firearm.

Pros: 

– Stunning replica of the 18th century pistol 

– Made from rust-resistant solid brass with a beautiful finish  

– Highly detailed hammer and trigger for an authentic look  

– Perfect for display or theatrical performances 

Cons

– No functional use.

Pietta 1858 Sheriff Benefits

pietta 1858 sheriff

The Pietta 1858 Sheriff is a replica of the classic American revolver from the mid-1800s. This faithful reproduction has all the features and details of the original, including an octagonal barrel, adjustable rear sight, case hardened frame with loading lever latch, and authentic brass trigger guard. 

The gun is made from durable materials that make it ideal for reenactments or as a collector’s item. It also has excellent accuracy and balance, making it perfect for target shooting. With its timeless design and reliable performance, the Pietta 1858 Sheriff is sure to be a hit among history buffs and firearm enthusiasts alike.

Factors To Consider When Choosing Pietta 1858 Sheriff

pietta 1858 sheriff

If you’re looking for a classic replica of an American revolver from the mid-1800s, then the Pietta 1858 Sheriff is a great choice. This faithful reproduction has all the features and details of the original, including an octagonal barrel, adjustable rear sight, case hardened frame with loading lever latch, and authentic brass trigger guard. It’s made from durable materials that make it ideal for reenactments or as a collector’s item. But before making your purchase decision there are some factors to consider when choosing this gun. 

Durability

The Pietta 1858 Sheriff is made from high-quality, durable materials that make it perfect for reenactments and other activities. It’s designed to last with its solid frame and robust construction. 

Accuracy & Balance 

The gun has excellent accuracy and balance, making it ideal for target shooting or any other activity that requires precision. 

Authenticity

The Pietta 1858 Sheriff is a faithful replica of the original American revolver from the mid-1800s. It has all the features and details of the original, making it perfect for collectors or anyone seeking an authentic piece to add to their collection. 

Cost 

It’s important to factor in cost when choosing a firearm. The Pietta 1858 Sheriff offers excellent value for money, with its high-quality materials and faithful design. 

Ease of Use 

The gun is easy to use and maintain, making it ideal for novice shooters and experienced firearms enthusiasts alike. It has a smooth trigger pull, adjustable rear sight, and loading lever latch for quick reloading. 

By taking the time to consider these factors, you can make an informed decision when it comes to buying a Pietta 1858 Sheriff. With its timeless design and reliable performance, this gun is sure to be a hit among history buffs and firearm enthusiasts

FAQs about Pietta 1858 Sheriff

pietta 1858 sheriff

Is the Pietta 1858 Sheriff a faithful replica of the original American revolver?

Answer: Yes, the Pietta 1858 Sheriff is an exact replica of the classic American revolver that was popular in the mid-1800s. It has all the features and details of the original, including an octagonal barrel, adjustable rear sight, case hardened frame with loading lever latch, and authentic brass trigger guard which makes it perfect for collectors or anyone seeking an authentic piece to add to their collection. 

What materials are used in its construction? 

Answer: The gun is made from high-quality rust-resistant solid brass with a beautiful finish that ensures years of use without any deterioration. It also boasts a highly detailed hammer and trigger for an authentic look as well as excellent accuracy and balance making it ideal for target shooting or any other activity that requires precision. 

Does this gun have functional use? 

Answer: Yes! Not only does this gun make a stunning display item but it also offers reliable performance due to its durable materials and timeless design making it ideal for reenactments or activities such as target shooting where accuracy matters most.  

How much does this firearm cost? 

Answer: The Pietta 1858 Sheriff is an affordable firearm with excellent value for money. It is competitively priced compared to other similar firearms of the same quality, making it a great choice for anyone looking for a reliable and authentic piece at an affordable price. 

Is this gun easy to use and maintain?

Answer: Yes! The Pietta 1858 Sheriff is easy to use and maintain, making it ideal for novice shooters and experienced firearms enthusiasts alike. It has a smooth trigger pull, adjustable rear sight, and loading lever latch for quick reloading so that you can quickly get back to shooting with ease. By taking the time to consider these factors, you can make an informed decision when it comes to buying a Pietta 1858 Sheriff. With its timeless design and reliable performance, this gun is sure to be a hit among history buffs and firearm enthusiasts!

Conclusion

The Pietta 1858 Sheriff is a faithful replica of the original American revolver from the mid-1800s, making it perfect for collectors or anyone seeking an authentic piece to add to their collection. It’s also constructed with high-quality materials and boasts excellent accuracy and balance, making it ideal for target shooting or any other activity that requires precision. Denix Model 1873 Lever Action Rifle is recommended.

Denix Model 1873 Lever Action Rifle, Antique Grey Finish - Non-Firing Replica
  • This is a non-firing version.
  • This product is restricted from shipment into the state of New York

 Moreover, it’s competitively priced compared to similar firearms of this quality, offering great value for money. With all these features combined, you can be sure that by investing in the Pietta 1858 Sheriff you will get a reliable firearm at an affordable price which would make a stunning addition to your gun collection!

Leave a Comment